Competition among restaurant point-of-sale providers is intense – but not nearly as ferocious as it once was, Shift4 Payments’ financial chief said last week.
Beyond Shift4, the POS field includes players such as Fiserv’s Clover unit, Block-owned Square, Global Payment’s Genius brand, NCR Voyix, Toast, Par Technology and Lightspeed Commerce, among others.
As fiercely as these vendors may compete on price, equipment and other terms, all of them aim for profits and act rationally on pricing as a result, Shift4 Chief Financial Officer Christopher Cruz said Tuesday at the KBW Fintech Ecosystem Conference.
“Believe it or not, this is not the most competitive time in restaurant technology and restaurant POS,” Cruz said in response to a question from KBW analyst Sanjay Sakhrani about industry competition, adding that investors expect point-of-sale players to pursue profitable growth.
The major U.S. POS companies are publicly traded, with shareholders. By contrast, venture capital-backed startups often can post losses for years.
“We’re glad that they have to be profitable as part of the benchmark, because competing with them when they didn't have to be, that was a tough time,” he said. “Once upon a time, there were multiple multi-billion-dollar unicorn restaurant POS companies” but they are no longer in the field, he added.
Cruz did not identify any of the unicorn companies to which he was referring.
“This is a very rational time to be a scaled incumbent participant in the restaurant technology and restaurant payment ecosystem, and we’re happy to be one of those players,” Cruz said, noting Shift4’s “decades” of operating experience since its 1999 founding.
Some large POS providers, including Square and Toast, have relied on discounting this year to goose growth. The price breaks have also come in response to inflation-driven hardware cost increases and merchants’ need to modernize their operations, analysts have said.
If Shift4 executives see “irrational activity” in the restaurant sector, the company is diversified and can “allocate capital towards where better unit economic returns can be had,” Cruz said.
Separately, in a sign of a rocky retail environment overseas, Shift4 said last week in its quarterly financial report that it had delayed some “commercial initiatives” planned in its European POS business this quarter. The company was responding to travel weakness from the Middle East and Asia to Europe owing to the Iran war, and recent political protests in France and Italy.
A spokesperson for Shift4 said the company had no further comments about the deferred initiatives or prior unicorn firms.
France, Italy and Spain are Shift4’s largest addressable European markets for travel-related shopping, said Cruz, a former Shift4 director and partner at private equity firm Searchlight Capital Partners, who became CFO in August 2025.
“If we had taken those commercial initiatives, it would have been, I think, the wrong decision strategically, wrong decision long term,” he said. “It would have been viewed as a very tone deaf approach, not acknowledging what was happening in the market.”
Correction: This story has been updated to reflect that Cruz’s comments were made last week.